Manchester City’s defensive crisis worsens as Nathan Ake joins John Stones and Manuel Akanji on the injury list, leaving Guardiola with limited options amid a crucial phase in multiple competitions.
Key Highlights
- Ake’s injury deepens City’s defensive crisis.
- Guardiola may have to rely on untested signings.
- City’s title hopes are in serious danger.
Guardiola’s Nightmares Continue – City’s Backline Takes Another Hit
Pep Guardiola must feel like he’s playing Jenga with his defence—every time he finds some stability, another key piece comes crashing down. This time, it’s Nathan Ake. The Dutch defender hobbled off at half-time during Manchester City’s 3-1 FA Cup win over Plymouth Argyle and Pep has now confirmed he’ll be out “for a long time.”
WHAT HAPPENED?
Nathan Ake started in City’s FA Cup fifth-round win but didn’t make it to the second half. Ruben Dias replaced him at half-time. Pep later confirmed the worst—Ake will be out for a long time, adding to City’s already long injury list.

Ake’s Injury is the Final Straw
Nathan Ake’s absence couldn’t have come at a worse time. City are already missing John Stones and Manuel Akanji and Rodri has been out for months. Pep had been rotating the squad masterfully but now with only Ruben Dias as a trusted option, the situation is dire.
“We will miss Nathan. I’m so grateful the club brought in Abdukodir Khusanov and Vitor Reis. Otherwise we’d have no chance of qualifying for the Champions League or the FA Cup. Impossible!”
Pep stated post-match.
Not exactly a confidence-boosting statement from a manager who doesn’t panic easily. But can you blame him? With fixtures piling up and City still in multiple competitions, losing a solid and versatile defender like Ake is a big blow.
THE BIGGER PICTURE
Man City are now without three defensive players in Nathan Ake, Stones and Akanji. With the busy schedule, Pep will have to make do with makeshift solutions. The defensive crisis could cost them in all competitions.
Nathan Ake’s injury is brutal timing. City are right in the title race, deep in the Champions League and chasing another FA Cup. But their defensive depth is paper-thin. Sure the January signings provide some cover but throwing in inexperienced defenders into big games isn’t exactly the solution.This also raises the question of how much can PepGuardiola rely on a small squad. His tactical acumen often covers for missing players but there’s only so much duct tape you can put on a crumbling defence before it collapses.

What Pep Guardiola
Pep said: “Now again we have a centre-back out for a long time, I think we’ll miss Nathan. I’m so grateful the club brought [Abdukodir] Khusanov and Vitor [Reis] otherwise we have no chance to qualify for the Champions League next season or to fight for the FA Cup. Impossible! We would just have [Ruben] Dias.”
Can City survive without Ake?
Losing Nathan Ake means Guardiola will have to use more makeshift solutions—perhaps pushing Rodri back into defence when he’s back or backing Khusanov to be ready straight away. Either way it’s a headache he could have done without.
City fans have seen their team rise above adversity before. But every defensive injury is another blow to their title hopes. If Guardiola can keep this squad together and competing on all fronts it might be his greatest achievement yet.
What’s Next?
City have a tough run of games in the league and Champions League. With Ake out, Guardiola needs to find a way to keep his side solid at the back. Will the January signings step up or will City struggle to cope with the growing injury list?
What do you think—can City hold on or is this the injury that derails their season?