Kylian Mbappe is in the spotlight again, and this time it’s not for his sick skills or a worldie finish. Carlo Ancelotti has given an interesting take on his recent struggles, calling his inconsistency “genetic.” But is that just an excuse, or does the Real Madrid boss have a point?
Key Highlights
- Mbappe’s form fluctuates: From a hat trick against City to a dry spell—what’s causing the inconsistency?
- Ancelotti’s genetic theory: Is Mbappe’s inconsistency truly in his DNA?
- A crucial test ahead: Can Mbappe bounce back and carry Madrid through vital matches?
Mbappe’s Rollercoaster
Mbappe was electric against Manchester City—4 goals in 2 games, a hat trick at the Bernabeu. He destroyed Pep’s team. But since then? Nothing. 3 games without a goal against Girona, Real Betis and Atletico Madrid. So the questions started coming.
“Bad? No,” Ancelotti said when asked if his Atletico performance was worthy of criticism. “He can’t always be at his best. Against City he scored 3, and against Atletico he didn’t. But that’s normal. Quality players have more ups and downs. It’s something genetic.” (According to Cadena SER)

The Science of Inconsistency
Genetic? Now that’s an interesting claim. Is Ancelotti saying that elite players struggle with consistency more than the others? It’s a bold statement, but it makes sense. High-risk, high-reward players like Mbappe live off instinct and flair. When it clicks, they’re unstoppable. When it doesn’t, they look lost.
The same has been true for superstars like Neymar and even prime Cristiano Ronaldo at times. The difference? Ronaldo adapted by refining his movement and shot selection. Mbappe still relies on his explosiveness. If he’s off, he offers nothing else.
Why Madrid Can’t Panic
Madrid fans might be getting worried, but let’s get some perspective. Despite this mini drought, Mbappé is Madrid’s top scorer with 28 goals in all competitions. If Madrid is still in the Champions League, it’s a lot down to him.
Ancelotti isn’t worried: “We’re very happy with him. If we’re in the last 16 of the Champions League, it’s a lot down to him.” Madrid’s season is far from over. They’re fighting for 3 trophies, though that 2-1 loss to Real Betis was a blow. With Barcelona and Atletico closing in on La Liga, every point counts.

What’s Next
Next up? A must-win LaLiga game against Rayo Vallecano, then the Champions League round of 16 second leg against Atletico at the Metropolitano. Then Villarreal. This is where Madrid needs Mbappe to snap out of his funk.
One thing’s for sure—he won’t stop being the talk of the town. This whole conversation disappears if he turns big in the next few weeks. If not? Well, expect more talk about genetics and consistency.
So, is Mbappe’s inconsistency really in his DNA, or is this just another phase of the season? Tell us, Madridistas.